I would of inserted the comment and name of the persons Channel too but on second thought decided to respect the privacy and name of the individual. I have decided to share only the reply for those who are wondering what sort of response a person might get when deciding to hurl their comments. The main thing I always try to insist on inshalah, as much as humanely possible, is to nip certain attitudes in the bud from the get go, and to emphasise akhlaq (manners and etiquetes) those who wish to continue in a fashion not becoming of a Muslim will not find they get further attention.
-----------------------------------------------------------
In the name of Allah and peace be upon His last messenger Muhammad ibn Abdullah (peace be upon him and his progeny).
Re: Reply to your remarks on my channel today, Thursday 16th September 2010.
Salam Alaykum,
Thankyou for visiting my Channel, I hope that we can exchange positive words inshallah. Before I mention anything concerning your charges of Shirk and Bid3ah, I would just like to say that unfortunately your comment will not be getting my approval nor will it be published so if you do have anything further to say please do so via email or using the personal message box until the comments reach a level of decency.
It is a shame that as a person that calls themself a Muslim you could say such comments on my channel. I did not publish it because those type of comments sholud be disscussed in private if the one writing such words can defend it. But in anycase maybe you said it out of emotinal anger and not out of calm thought, as is the case with some of our Muslim brothers.
I see (from the advetised websites on your channel) that you are the type of Salafi that they call Madkhali and I know there are many types of so called Salafis every group claiming that they are the real Salafis and the real Ahlus sunnah but each calling the other names, like Ahlul Bid3ah and worse.
It seems these days that as much as a person seeks to identify themselves purely as Muslim they will always be seen in a certain way according to the websites that they advertise or the Scholars that they speak about or the views they hold.
For this reason it is important in this day and age, with all the different types of Muslims and views, that we get our facts correct and be precise in our words and try to be less like people who do not have much else except for accusations and violence, usually these type of people are the weakest.
This is one of the reasons why I set up this channel to help brothers and sisters like you. Some groups seem to think that they hold the keys to heaven and hell, condeming other Muslims left, right and centre.
We are not under any obligation to go around calling people Kafir or Mushrikeen but we are under an obligation to call people to Islam using wisdom and good words. Therefore if Muslims wish to be sincere in their calling to the religion of Islam let them remember the manners and beauty and attraction of the Prophet in his dealings with hypocrites, disbelievers, Christians, Jews, weak companions etc. These people did not become Muslims due to the Prophet going around calling them names and abusing them. Even when the Prophet was abused and called names he was not like some people who if you call them a name they are ready to abuse all your family or worse. The Prophet was spat at and stoned but he rose above his anger and petty name calling.
Some people claim to be calling to Islam via websites and scholars but are calling to the devil in their actions and words. We should correct these things and look at the defects in ourselves. If we have a point to make we should also make it using books, page numbers and print edition, and not copy paste from sites that are fuelled by hatred.
May Allah forgive me if I have offended you in anything I have said to you and may Allah forgive you your words and accusations. May Allah increase us all in knowledge of His religion and in the manners and the way of the Propet Muhammad peace be upon him and his family.
With Regards
Yours in Islam
Wa Salams.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment